This week, a CMC double feature as our favorite trio of fillies continue their ongoing quest for identities and talents of their own. In Stare Master, the CMC have a sleepover/planning session at Fluttershy’s after various creative mishaps (along with Sweetie Belle’s somewhat tense relationship with her older sister Rarity) make staying at the Boutique a non-starter. So off they go to spend the night at the house of Ponyville’s ground-bound pegasus!
For all the grief I gave Dragonshy earlier in the season, it did include one of my favorite early Fluttershy moments: the one where she talks down a dragon with a strong resemblance to Smaug for hurting her friends, and gets him to fly off somewhere else so his snoring doesn’t plunge the land into an ecological catastrophe. Her wide-eyed expression during that confrontation becomes known as The Stare, and evidently it’s become quite well known in the time between then and now, if Rarity’s asking about it at the top of the episode.
Savino does a good job establishing the Stare’s power and hints at the conclusion when he has Twilight go into the Everfree Forest to get some tea, entirely on her own, without anypony there to help her in case something goes wrong, which of course it does. Off-screen, poor Twilight quickly becomes the victim of a cockatrice: a monstrous creature with the head of a chicken and the body of a snake, which has the ability to petrify people by staring at them. (Sound familiar?)
The cockatrice is the perfect monster for Fluttershy to face, since they have broadly the same ability, but wield it for very different purposes: the cockatrice uses its power to hurt people, while Fluttershy uses it on recalcitrant animals to get them to behave. She soon gets her chance when the CMC indirectly cause one of Fluttershy’s chickens to fly the coop, and they run into the forest to find her, in an attempt to become Cutie Mark Crusaders chicken rescuers.
Fluttershy, understandably afraid of the forest, goes in after them and is horrified to find Twilight’s petrified body in a clearing, which clues her in to the presence of the cockatrice. When the CMC accidentally discover it, she dives in to protect them and uses the Stare, getting the cockatrice to stop what it’s doing even as she’s being petrified herself:
“You! Just who do you think you are, going around turning others into stone? You should be ashamed of yourself. I have a mind to find your mother and tell her what you’ve been up to, young man. Now you go over there, and turn Elizabeak and my friend Twilight back to normal, and don’t ever let me catch you doing this again. Do you understand me?”
I absolutely love this moment. Fluttershy is a difficult character to write correctly because of how naturally kind and sweet she is, she can come off as an extreme doormat, particularly in this season. That said, she does have moments of strength, such as this one with the cockatrice, and in other situations (which we’ll get to later in the series) she can use her kindness to her advantage during a fight by faking out her opponents. She would, I feel, be an excellent companion for the Doctor, if they ever met.
Moving along to The Show Stoppers, I actually didn’t like this episode very much when I first watched it a decade ago, mainly because of the disastrous musical number at the end, and at the time, the CMC were not exactly my favorite characters. But now that I look at it, I’m actually quite fond of it.
Finding out what you want to be when you grow up is hard work, and there are no easy solutions! It makes complete sense for you to try out as many different things as possible, because you’ll never know where they might lead. For example: I spent most of my teen years wanting to go to college and major in something relating to music, so I learned to play the guitar, then went to college and got a bachelor’s degree in audio production.
I excelled in post-production work: mixing and mastering previously recorded tracks, sound design, and even editing podcasts. And while I remain interested in that to an extent, what I’ve since realized is that I have a talent for writing too, honed from years of online role-plays or school essay assignments. That turned into blogging, which turned into writing a book, with more on the way. I certainly wouldn’t have imagined that I’d have a small but enjoyable career as a media critic when I was fifteen, but that’s part of growing up: exploration.
And while the song at the end of the episode is still kind of hard to listen to and watch, it’s by no means bad. The lyrics are an excellent anthem for growing up and the frustration we all felt as kids, wanting to be adults because they got to do all the cool stuff. And you have to admire the CMC’s dedication to their craft, even as they attempt to do things that really aren’t their respective fortes. (At times, Scootaloo banging her head into the piano is such a mood.)
My favorite little moment from this episode may be Sweetie Belle’s admission that she experiences stage fright even as she admits she’s a good singer. She might be comforted to know that no less than Paul McCartney, one of the greatest songwriters and performers in the history of music, went through it during the early years of his career with The Beatles. (And before someone tells me there aren’t any Beatles in Equestria, there are. And Pinkie was Ringo.)
Watching this pair of episodes was something of a nostalgic experience for me, because I found myself remembering a couple of old fandom memes: the in-joke about Scootaloo being a chicken, and the extended guesswork about what the CMC’s cutie marks would be in the event that they finally earned them, inspired by their true talents as hinted at during the extended attempts at putting their performance together. (This kind of thing happens to you when you’ve been in the fandom from the beginning…)
Anyway! I do hope you like Rarity, because when we return next week we have two of her episodes, and in my opinion they are both quite strong.
Leave a Reply