Equestria Forever: A Dog and Pony Show/Green Isn’t Your Color

One imagines that prior to writing A Dog and Pony Show, Amy Keating Rogers must have watched the animated 1968 Beatles movie Yellow Submarine. That movie was an attempt by the band to fulfill their three-film contract with United Artists, and is considered a landmark of animation. The reason I bring it up here is mainly because of “Hey Bulldog” – a relative deep-cut in Beatle circles, and only featured on the Yellow Submarine album(s) and film, though the sequence in question was originally cut out of the version screened in the US.

I adore “Hey Bulldog,” it’s one of my favorite Beatles rock numbers, but I would also like to shout out the excellent parody version released by the Beatle Bronies in August 2011. Their song was directly inspired by the episode, and focuses on the Diamond Dogs themselves rather than Rarity – kind of like a perspective-flipped version of the episode, all in about 3 minutes. It’s fantastic!

What I like about the episode proper is its commitment to fleshing out Rarity’s personality. She’s a bit like a character out of a Jane Austen novel: witty and confident with a keen business sense and the ability to read people quickly, and unafraid to get into physical combat when the need arises, as in the series pilot when she bucks a manticore in the face.

What this episode does is it takes those aspects of her character and places them into what looks for all the world like a traditional “damsel in distress” storyline, from the rest of Rarity’s friends uniting to come to her rescue down to Spike coming to her rescue on a noble steed (well, a thoroughly unamused Twilight Sparkle) and generally acting like the Prince Charming character seen in any number of Disney movies based on fairy tales, or the extremely weird Russian movie Morozko. (Otherwise known as Jack Frost.)

But Rogers executes a bait-and-switch: rather than have Rarity be forever at the mercy of the Diamond Dogs unable to defend herself, she instead is able to turn the situation to her advantage. Her voice apparently vibrates in the eardrums of the dogs at such a pitch that it hurts them to hear it, so she whines in her shrillest, most nasal tone and is soon able to get herself out of the harness and given a glass of water.

This would be wonderful in and of itself, but casting Tabitha St. Germain as Rarity’s voice actress, who can really bring on the ham when the script calls for it, elevates the entire exercise to a whole new level. Germain is a talented voice actress all by herself (she voices somewhere around sixty different characters over the series) and for Rarity, she goes full on drama queen, and this is just the first season. There will be more.

Readers of my Doctor Who blogs are probably aware by now that I am very fond of stories about women who are able to get themselves out of tough situations without relying on men to rescue them, or even better, use what feminine qualities they possess in order to rescue other people. (Rose Tyler defeating the Nestene Consciousness with gymnastics in her eponymous episode springs to mind.) This episode ticks all those boxes for me, on top of the fact that it features Rarity, my second-favorite pony after Twilight.

Of course, there are two sides to every story, and the second episode we’ll be looking at is the dark twin to A Dog and Pony Show. If that one goes to great lengths to depict Rarity’s positive traits, this one emphasizes her more negative ones, albeit not so harshly as to turn her into a full on villain.

Green Isn’t Your Color focuses on Rarity and Fluttershy: in the episode, Fluttershy inadvertently becomes a successful fashion model when a famous photographer, Photo Finish, discovers her during a visit to Carousel Boutique. Over the course of the episode, Rarity is clearly jealous of her friend’s success (mainly because Photo Finish blows her off) but tries to be the better pony all the same. While she admits to Twilight during a visit to the spa, “I wish that star would burn out,” she takes no action to actually ensure that it does.

The irony is that Fluttershy, being who she is, hates her new job as a fashion model, and makes no effort to hide her discomfort to everypony except Rarity, to whom she pretends to love it so as to not disappoint her, even though she confesses her true feelings to Twilight in the same scene as Rarity, though not at the same time.

This sort of scenario is referred to as an Abilene Paradox, in which “a group of people collectively decide on a course of action that is counter to the preferences of many or all of the individuals in the group.” The term was coined by Jerry B. Harvey in his 1974 article “The Abilene Paradox: The Management of Agreement,” and is so named because of an anecdote he gives in which a family takes a trip to Abilene, New York when all they really wanted to do was stay home, but no one was comfortable expressing disagreement with the plan.

Not helping matters is Pinkie Pie: at the start of the episode, she and Twilight promise Spike that they won’t say anything about Spike’s extremely obvious crush on Rarity, (which he seems to think is a complete secret) and Pinkie extends this vow of silence to Rarity and Fluttershy’s respective admissions about modeling, citing that “losing a friend’s trust is the fastest way to lose a friend forever!”

And to be fair to Pinks, this is a true statement. However, in a situation like the one that Rarity and Fluttershy face, keeping quiet as Twilight tries to do on Pinkie’s insistence actually makes the situation worse, as an attempt by Twilight to sabotage Fluttershy’s next fashion show goes awry when Rarity, after everypony else in the room is reacting with disgust to Fluttershy’s magically-induced unattractiveness, applauds her instead.

It’s only when Rarity goes backstage to congratulate Fluttershy that the truth finally comes out (on both sides) and Twilight learns the following lesson: “Being a good friend means being able to keep a secret. But you should never be afraid to share your true feelings with a good friend.”

In a twist of fate, this episode has new relevance for me in a way it didn’t when I first watched it fifteen years ago, as a new fan of the series. Rarity’s part of the dilemma reminds me very much of a situation from my own life: in October 2020, I released a book called Back to the Eleventh Hour, about the fifth revival series of Doctor Who. It proved to be quite popular, and was in fact the second blogging project I considered publishing, the first being Adventures in Narrative Substitution.

At the time, I had a friend called Sam Maleski: they were a media critic and essayist like I was, and had actually given me my start in the field by allowing me to publish Narrative Substitution on their own blog, and encouraged me in all future endeavors… at least to my face.

In private, around other people, Maleski was incandescently furious about things like my original plan to publish Narrative Substitution (which he felt would have eaten into sales of his own book about the Chibnall era) and then about the success of Eleventh Hour when it was the number one new release in its category on Amazon the week it came out.

It’s worth mentioning that Sam never told me any of this themself: he was accused of sexual and emotional abuse at the start of 2021 by myself and two other women, (in my case primarily emotional abuse) and everything I’ve mentioned in the previous paragraph was related to me well after the fact by other people. I’ll never know if he felt any remorse for being such a vicious two-faced bastard, but given he had a vendetta against Big Finish writer Sophie Iles for the unforgivable sin of rejecting a story he wrote for a project because it was too long, I can only assume that the answer would be no.

I suppose, looking back, Sam Maleski reminds me somewhat of Rarity: both are driven individuals with designs on becoming The Absolute Best in their respective fields, (fashion design and media criticism respectively) speak with posh accents, and have a tendency toward vanity, and make a show of being generous and kind around their friends… except in Rarity’s case, she really is that generous and kind.

She makes a genuine effort to put her jealousy to one side for the sake of her friendship with Fluttershy, even reproving herself when she realizes she’s being jealous, and more to the point, she comes clean with her friend of her own volition, rather than being forced to by Twilight. Yes, she’s still hurting Fluttershy when she applauds at the fashion show (increasing Fluttershy’s popularity in the process) but not intentionally so. She wants her friend to succeed, and is willing to do whatever she can to make sure that happens.

Contrast this with what Maleski did: he encouraged me to get published, yet complained so furiously about how well my book did that our publisher was actually afraid to advertise it in public for fear of attracting his wrath. There was always a definite sense from him that he cared more about advancing his career than making and keeping friends, and was aways ready to stomp on anyone who got in his way if it meant he got to move up the ladder.

I suppose, given I now have four actual published books with my name on it, several blog series, and I’m head writer on an original science fiction project, this means I have a career as a professional writer, albeit a very small one. I don’t have designs on becoming well-known, I’m just happy to write about the topics that interest me and hope that other people might find my opinions worth reading. When it comes to helping other people working in a similar niche to mine, I’m always happy to offer encouragement, because like Rarity, I want to see them succeed too.

By the end of the series, Rarity has more than just a career: she has three different boutiques in three different cities and probably more besides, whereas Sam had all his future projects canceled, got removed from the ones he was already involved with, and has generally disappeared off the face of the earth since the allegations came out.

Suffice to say, I’d much rather be friends with Rarity than Sam Maleski.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑