Captain’s log, stardate 81310.4: While tending to innocent bystanders, Doctor Crusher is taken hostage by a ruthless freedom fighter who is blind to the fate of his rebellion and refuses to hear any argument from the Starfleet officers or the local law enforcers.
This week, we say goodbye to Melinda Snodgrass with “The High Ground,” what would’ve been TNG’s take on the American Revolution, but with a twist: the crew of the Enterprise would’ve been on the side of the Redcoats, with the Romulans acting in the role of the French. (And presumably, the Rutians would’ve played the part of the Continentals.)
As Snodgrass described it: “I wanted it with Picard as Cornwallis and the Romulans would have been the French, who were in our revolution, trying to break this planet away. Suddenly Picard realized he’s one of the oppressors.” Which, if that had been the episode we got, would’ve played to Trek’s strengths more, to say nothing of being able to put Patrick Stewart, an actual Brit, in the role played by his own countrymen.
But instead, that’s not what we got. Someone (Underhill thinks it was Roddenberry) higher up the chain than Snodgrass instead decided that the thing to do was to dramatize the Troubles, which started in the late Sixties and ended around 30 years later in 1998, when Insurrection was being filmed.
We’ve talked about the Troubles before here on the blog – rather infamously, both John Lennon and Paul McCartney decided to respond to the Bloody Sunday massacre of January 1972 with protest songs: “Give Ireland Back to the Irish” for Paul, which got released as a single, and “Luck of the Irish” and “Sunday Bloody Sunday” for John, both of which appeared on his decidedly unloved Some Time in New York City.
I suppose I can see what they were thinking – both of them were one half of the most beloved pop songwriting team of the 20th century and former Beatles to boot. Add in their Irish ancestry and, in the words of Jeremy Clarkson, “How hard can it be?”
The answer, as we know from Four Sides of the Circle, was very hard. While all three of the songs are profoundly terrible, they are bad for different reasons: Paul had never written a protest song in his life before, which is how you get to lines like complimenting the government you’re castigating in the very next verse.
John, at least, had a history of protest songs behind him, having written several going all the way back to the Beatles track “Revolution” from 1968. His problem was that no matter how well-intentioned his Troubles songs were, “Sunday Bloody Sunday”’s message is quickly bogged down by Lennon’s anger, while “Luck of the Irish” alternates John’s verses, which at least try to illustrate just how bad the Irish have had it from the British over the centuries. with Yoko’s ones about shamrocks and leprechauns and shit.
The best thing to come out of John’s “Sunday Bloody Sunday,” if you ask me, is the 7-minute music video that gives a typographical overview not just of the inciting incident, but also the subsequent investigation carried out between 1998 to 2010, and it widens the scope to talk about all sorts of armed conflicts, wars, mass shootings, and terrorist attacks, from Vietnam to 9/11 and the Ukraine and Gaza wars.
(And it ends, of course, with remarking that over 1,500,000 people have been killed with guns since John’s murder in December 1980.)
But the thing is, and I can’t believe I’m saying this, at least John and Paul had something to say about the Troubles. Being men of Irish descent, they understood that what Britain had been doing to that country over the centuries was wrong on a wide variety of levels – they just lacked the capacity to adequately get to the heart of things.
Because after all, they were Englishmen anyway. They’re not any more native Irish than I am.
So, what exactly does Star Trek: The Next Generation have to say about the Troubles in general, if not Bloody Sunday in particular?
Basically, nothing. And that’s not just my opinion, both Michael Piller and Ronald D. Moore thought so too:
Moore: “It’s our one terrorist show. We didn’t have anything interesting to say about terrorism except that it’s bad and Beverly gets kidnapped – ho hum. They take her down to the caves and we get to have nice, big preachy speeches about terrorism and freedom, fighting and security forces versus society. It’s a very unsatisfying episode and the staff wasn’t really happy with it.”
Likewise, Michael Piller commented, “Another show that I wasn’t particularly happy with. We set out to do a show about terrorists. What was the statement we made about terrorism in the show? Was it the point where the boy puts down the gun and says, ‘Maybe the end of terrorism is when the first child puts down his gun?’ It was effective in the context of that show, but is certainly not a statement that provides any great revelation. You must be prepared to say something new about social issues.”
In any event, the episode didn’t air on British TV until 2007, seventeen years after its US release, and it hasn’t aired on Irish TV at all – though chances are, Irish Trekkies have probably seen it anyway, due to DVD and Blu-Ray releases there. Certainly, the choice to frame the separatists as being freedom fighters watches very differently 20 some years after the War on Terror.
True, the American Revolution story we didn’t get would’ve been propaganda of an entirely different sort, but at least that has precedence in Trek history – in the TOS episode The Omega Glory, the Iowan Captain Kirk (played by noted Canadian William Shatner) dramatically recites the preamble to the US Constitution, with stirring music and an American flag in the background.
But the Troubles? If you ask me, the only people allowed to speak on that subject are actual Irish people. Enter U2 with their own song called “Sunday Bloody Sunday,” which takes a far more expansive view. After all, their song was released in 1983, 11 years after the events of the title. Times have changed but the Troubles continue, lending their song an air of real anguish mixed in with the anger, but also hope, as depicted in the song’s choruses.
Listening to their song now, in 2026, as Christian nationalists infiltrate the US government and launch wars in the Middle East with the express intention of causing the Rapture, U2’s Christian pacifism (as Rolling Stone described it in 2019) feels like a much-needed counterweight. Here are some Christians who are actually trying to live their faith as it is, rather than inverting and twisting it to fit pre-conceived opinions.
Note to self: Do a U2 project at some point in the future.
Leave a Reply