Captain’s log, stardate 81326.8: Q returns to the Enterprise, but this time his immortality and his powers have been rescinded by the members of the Continuum, and he must help the crew to deal with an asteroid that threatens to devastate an entire civilization.
As I often do when I write about Star Trek, I like to check in with L.I. Underhill on the episode of the week to see what they thought of it. Most of the time, I find that our opinions on the episodes in question vary to different degrees, particularly when we’re talking about episodes that I love and they despise. “Deja Q,” TNG’s fourth Q story and his first as a solo act since season 1, is a case in point. I’ve always liked the episode, ever since I first watched it back in 2022, and Underhill… well. Hatred feels a bit like an understatement:
“Deja Q” is unquestionably near the top of the list of episodes I most dreaded having to cover, and it remains one of my least favourite episodes in the entire franchise. This is Star Trek: The Next Generation at its absolute most cloyingly unwatchable, from its sappy milquetoast humanism to its unbearably forced, tuneless, shockingly out-of-touch cornball “zaniness” and its dangerously slipshod grasp of utopianism.
I don’t like to make a habit of responding directly to my fellow critics like this (especially as the post in question is eleven years old and Underhill hasn’t written anything for Eruditorum Press since 2018) but in this case, I feel like I have to make an exception. Everything Underhill says in the above quote, for me, represents the episode’s strengths, not its flaws, and I’m going to explain why.
Let’s start with the basic premise of the episode. Back in “Q Who,” our titular chaos god dropped in on the Enterprise crew with the goal of joining their ranks:
Q: My purpose is to join you.
RIKER: To join us as what?
Q: As a member of the crew. Willing and able. Ready to serve. This ship is already home for the indigent, the unwanted, the unworthy. Why not for a homeless entity.
RIKER: Homeless?
Q: Yes.
The Continuum, we learn, kicked Q out and now he’s wanting someplace else to belong to, so of course the Enterprise is the first place he thinks of to go. Obviously, nothing came of that plot line because the writers decided to introduce the Borg that week instead, with Q serving as the intermediary.
But even so, doing a “Q as a member of the Enterprise” story wouldn’t have worked for the simple reason that, in fanfiction terms, Q is a bit of a Mary Sue: overpowered and able to do literally anything without breaking a sweat. Then the question becomes, how do you write a plot thread like that without Q immediately breaking the story to shreds?
The answer is to strip him of his powers altogether, rendering him human. “Deja Q” sets itself up with a premise that’s almost identical to his last appearance, but with that aforementioned little twist. All of a sudden, the episode is able to explore this premise to the limit: Q as a crewman, and the reactions of the regulars as they try to work with (or more accurately, around) him.
It does not go well. Q is plainly terrible at being a Starfleet officer, both because he’s too much of an arrogant asshole to actually be of much help, and because he’s too used to being omnipotent, so he complains about it all the time. What makes this work, though, is John de Lancie – he is a fabulous comedic actor, as the bridge scene following the opening credits illustrates quite nicely.
After three episodes of him lording it over the Enterprise crew, it is delightful to see him get taken down several notches: Patrick Stewart is clearly relishing getting a chance to have Picard give a little petty revenge, as when he decides to answer Q’s request to be treated as a human by having him thrown in the brig, and of course there’s this glorious moment between Q and Worf:
Q: Q the miserable. Q the desperate. What must I do to convince you people?
WORF: Die.
It’s the bluntness of the word that really sells it, to say nothing of Dorn’s straight-faced expression as he says the line. (Underhill never even mentions it, which is a crying shame – it really is one of TNG’s funniest moments.)
What makes the episode really shine though, at least for me, is the decision to contrast Q with Data. Where most of his shipmates in the main cast treat Q with varying amounts of open disdain and disgust, Data is nothing but respectful of him, to the point that he becomes Q’s advocate, as Troi coolly observes in an observation lounge scene around halfway through.
Why is this? Part of it just comes down to who Data is. The rest of Team Enterprise are too caught up in their distrust and dislike of Q to really give him a fair chance, but Data? He takes Q at his word, tries to offer advice to him, and even sacrifices himself to save Q when the Calamarain attack again.
Whether Q is deserving of this treatment or not, for Data, is utterly immaterial. He gives Q a chance when no one else would, and in so doing, reminds me of another character who did the same thing for an omnipotent god played with relish by John de Lancie – Fluttershy and Discord, as seen in the MLP episode “Keep Calm and Flutter On.”
Aired as part of that show’s third season, the premise centers on Princess Celestia tasking the mane six with reforming Discord, and just as with the Enterprise crew, a majority of the leads are against the idea, treating Discord with large amounts of suspicion and distrust. Only Fluttershy, Bearer of Kindness, treats him with anything like the respect that Data treats Q with, and it’s her friendship that causes Discord to switch sides thereafter.
Both of these reformations go on to have lasting effects in both series – Discord, aside from being briefly tempted back to evil by Tirek in “Twilight’s Kingdom,” spends the rest of Friendship is Magic as an unambiguous good guy, albeit one with a slightly warped sense of good and evil. Similarly, Q goes from merely tormenting humanity for the sake of it to becoming a “trickster mentor” instead, leading to episodes like “Tapestry” in season six. (Or, in a very roundabout way, all of PIC’s second season.)
And besides – considering how deadly serious both episodes immediately before and after it are, “Deja Q” being a rare Trek comedy is a much-needed breath of fresh air. We even get a brief expansion of the Continuum here, something that will become very important when we get to Star Trek: Voyager and its trilogy of Q episodes.
Besides, it’s John de Lancie. That man makes anything worth watching.
Leave a Reply