Captain’s log, stardate 81348.3: Riker is accused of murder after the apparent sabotage and destruction of a science station, but Picard and Troi gamble on using the Holodeck to recreate testimonies from all the surviving parties.
The murder mystery: a classic genre so beloved that practically every franchise out there, no matter what it is, eventually does one. Back in March we talked about My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic borrowing the structure of Agatha Christie and fusing it with Sherlock Holmes in order to tell a story about who could’ve eaten the enormous cake that was meant to be taken to a dessert competition.
Or there’s the Doctor Who episode “Mummy on the Orient Express,” where it turns out the entire murder mystery element is a conceit created by Gus, who is more or less GLaDOS from Portal only aggressively posh and cheerful in the way that many non-villainous British characters tend to be when they’re written by Americans. (You half expect him to utter a “pip pip cheerio!” at the end of his lines.)
In any event, if you know me, then chances are you know I love a good murder mystery, be it games of Werewolf in my Discord server, or the fantastic Witch Way Librarian Mysteries by Angela M. Sanders. In those books, a librarian discovers she’s a witch and finds herself working as an amateur sleuth, solving the profusion of murder cases with the help of her friends in the small Oregon town they call home.
“A Matter of Perspective” is Star Trek’s version of a murder mystery, though the format they use here is quite different to the ones I’ve mentioned. This one follows the plot of the Japanese film Rashomon: a man is murdered, and the stories come from a sexually desirable man (Riker), the murdered man’s wife who may or may not have had an affair with him (Manua), and the murdered man himself (Dr. Apgar).
Obviously, Riker is already having a bad day. Just from the tone of his voice when he initially gives his beam-up order in the cold open, he is not happy, and his near silence in the bridge scene that follows the opening credits makes it even clearer. We are left to wonder what exactly it was that went down there, and even if some aspects of the situation are clear-cut, others are left purposefully ambiguous.
In keeping with the format established in the original film, we don’t see the original events play out – all we have to go on is the unreliable testimony of Manua, Apgar, and Riker, with Picard forced into the role of needing to decide Riker’s fate. It’s an unhappy episode for any number of reasons, not the least of which is the way it takes one aspect of Riker’s character (his status as a ladies’ man) and warps it into something you see all the time in our world, but not the decidedly cleaner world of Star Trek.
Being accused of murder is bad enough, but late in the episode we learn of a second charge from Manua: Attempted rape. Let’s go to the transcript:
MANUA: Commander, please. It’s late and I’m tired.
RIKER: A man more interested in Krieger waves than in a lovely woman like you. How is that possible?
MANUA: My husband is one of the great minds in the galaxy and we love each other very much.
(Riker pulls her towards him)
MANUA: Please don’t.
RIKER: It must be very lonely. A princess in a very high tower.
MANUA: Please, my husband will be looking for me.
RIKER: Your sanctuary, remember?
(Riker slips her dress off her shoulders)
This episode was made in 1990, decades before the MeToo movement began and demanded accountability against prominent men in entertainment and politics for sexual crimes. But even so, it’s genuinely unsettling to see someone like William Riker, who has always presented himself as a stand-up guy, be accused of such an appalling crime. Troi’s statement just before the scene break that everyone is telling the truth “as they remember it” doesn’t help matters.
That aspect of the story is never definitely resolved – instead, the last quarter of the episode is devoted to proving what really happened regarding the events leading up to the explosion. As the trope page has it, “Apgar had secretly completed his work on Krieger waves. The radiation spikes around the ship were actually Krieger waves being reflected off the holodeck’s version of Apgar’s completed machine. Apgar was planning to sell it for use as a weapon rather than give it to the Federation, which is why he was nervous about Riker’s early visit. After seeing Riker with his wife, Apgar decided to use his Krieger waves to kill Riker and make it look like a transporter accident. But the Krieger wave that Apgar fired at Riker bounced off the transporter beam and reflected back into the machine, causing it to explode.”
Grim shit, all around, but it ends with Riker’s name being cleared – he’s even allowed to set the course and give a warp jump order. All that leaves is the question of what exactly went down between him and Manua in the station’s guest quarters.
Personally? Since we primarily follow the crew of the Enterprise on this show, I think it’s a pretty safe bet that Riker’s version of the events is the closest to the truth. In his telling, it’s Manua who tries to force herself on Riker, only for him to reject her advances. He loudly denies the accusations made against him, and unlike real people, who can deny those sorts of things all they want and still be guilty, Riker is a fictional character. For him to do these things would be wildly out of character. Sure, he’s a slut, but he’s an ethical slut!
Well, okay, he is until the movies when he settles down with Troi. But even so, he’d never do anything like what Manua accuses him of. While I don’t think she was lying per se, I do think she was wildly exaggerating what happened, and given that this planet’s legal system is explicitly said to be “guilty until proven innocent,” much like Q’s courtroom in “Encounter at Farpoint,” things could’ve gone very badly indeed for Will had Data, Geordi, and Wesley not found the metaphorical smoking gun when they did. In any event, this episode was a huge drag, and I usually like murder mysteries.
Good thing next week is, for my money, the crown jewel of the entire series and my favorite episode of Star Trek, period. It’s the one that when my wife watched it with me after viewing “Skin of Evil,” she called it perfect. It’s the episode that made me the Star Trek fan I am today, and it was the first episode of TNG I ever saw on purpose, rather than half listening to because my parents were watching. It’s the episode I’ve watched more than any other.
It’s “Yesterday’s Enterprise.”
Leave a Reply