If you’re a Beatles fan of a certain age (like me, one of the original Anthology babies) then you probably remember how much of the 2000s were spent watching the digital music boom that kicked off with the launch of the iTunes Music Store in 2003. It was a massive success, but there were some big names missing from the digital shelves… particularly the Fab Four.
That’s not to say the boys weren’t involved with Apple (Inc) at all. In fact, in 2008 Bloomingdale’s sold a special Beatles-themed iPod as part of a box set with sixteen albums on CD – the thirteen core catalog albums plus Past Masters (in its original two-volume configuration) and Love. Starting from around 2007 or so, it was possible to buy the solo works of John, Paul, George, and Ringo, but nothing by the biggest band in the history of popular music… unless you were into generic soundalikes.
But in 2010, everything changed when the entire core catalogue was released on iTunes that November, including Past Masters (now in its two-disc single volume configuration) and the Red and Blue compilations. The main three Anthology albums were released on iTunes in June 2011, along with a new release: Anthology Highlights, which as the title suggests collects together the best selections from the trilogy, bookended by the two reunion tracks.
When the Anthology project was revived in 2025 for its 30th anniversary, among the new releases was a revamped version of Anthology Highlights. The new Highlights has 9 more total tracks plus a different song selection from the original release, so I’ve decided to cover them separately.
Let’s dive in, starting with 2011:
‘Free As A Bird’: Advertised as the first new Beatles track in 25 years, “Bird” is one of three Beatles songs that began as demo recordings by John Lennon from the late 1970s, during his hiatus from the music industry. Some of the lyrics were unfinished, which meant Paul got to do a little bit of collaborating with his old partner once again.
It’s a beautiful number, and while some people think it sounds a bit too much like ELO and less like the Beatles of the ‘60s, I personally feel like “Bird” is more like an evolution in their sound… the kind of thing they did in the 60s with every freaking album.
One After 909 (complete): One of the earliest attempts we have of the Beatles trying to play “One After 909,” a very early Lennon-McCartney song surrounding an ill-fated train journey. They do their best, but the energy isn’t quite there – it’s not until 1969, when they play it on the roof of Apple HQ, that they nail it.
‘That Means A Lot’: Another unreleased song, written and recorded around the time of “Ticket to Ride,” (which it sonically resembles) but with Paul on lead vocals. It’s not bad, though the version presented here is absolutely soaked in reverb and slapback echo, for some reason.
‘Leave My Kitten Alone’: I find it interesting that this song is presented in mono, or at least very narrow stereo, when the recording of it in an Anthology episode is in wider stereo. Still, I like this song – kind of reminiscent of “You’re Going to Lose That Girl,” and we get to hear John go into his higher register briefly. Though recorded during the Beatles For Sale sessions, the boys opted to put “Mr. Moonlight” on instead – a shame, because this is better.
‘If You’ve Got Trouble’: Intended to be RIngo’s vocal spot on Help!, the boys were ultimately not happy with this song, so they used “Act Naturally” instead. Honestly, I kind of like it? Like a more successful version of “Honey Don’t” from Beatles For Sale.
‘Can’t Buy Me Love’: Two early takes of the hit from A Hard Day’s Night, recorded in France in January 1964. Note there are some backing vocals in here that don’t appear in the finished track. Also listen for Paul getting some of the words wrong… or just forgetting them entirely!
‘Mr Moonlight’: Still a terrible song, though only because the words are cheesy as all hell.
‘Kansas City/Hey-Hey-Hey-Hey!’: An earlier take of the other Missouri-related Beatles song in their catalogue, just before the master. I’d almost confuse them for each other, they sound so much alike.
“Eight Days a Week (Takes 1, 2 4, 5): Before we got the fade-in that opens the master, we got some pretty oohs instead! Nice enough, but they don’t really work too well.
‘I’m Looking Through You’: The album version of this song is one of the best Beatles breakup songs ever, especially the bridge sections… which do not exist in this recording, because they haven’t been written yet. It’s a good performance, but the slower tempo takes some of the edge off the song, to its detriment.
‘Yesterday’: An early take of Paul’s signature Beatles song (well, one of them) where he instructs someone on the chords… despite being the only guitarist on the recording. Also note the line swap at the start of the second verse! Always a bit jarring, after having heard the album version for so long. Still, that it’s just Paul and his guitar singing really brings home the loneliness of the song, and it’s lovely.
‘Tomorrow Never Knows’: Originally called “The Void,” this early version of Revolver’s closing track is kind of great, in a “here is how it started” sort of way. Almost hypnotic, when stripped of tape loops and reversed guitar parts. Note that John’s voice has the Leslie effect on it for the entire song, rather than just the last third.
‘Strawberry Fields Forever’ (Take 1): Take 1 of this wonderful song, and gradually, you can hear the track take shape. It’s not quite finished yet, but it’s getting there. This version is just John, his guitar, and a Mellotron – the take as released on the Sgt. Pepper box set has the gorgeous backing vocals added back in, making it sound like his version of “Here, There, and Everywhere.”
‘Across The Universe’: An earlier version of the song than the one that’s been remixed three or four different times since 1968, with added sound effects. According to the liner notes, “Here, for the first time, is an unembellished and alternative recording of Across The Universe, Take 2, recorded on Saturday 3 February 1968 in EMI Studio Three, temporarily marked “best” on the tape box and so afforded overdubs and technical wonders like the phasing on John’s guitar and the percussion.”
‘Something’: The final demo from George’s solo session – a heartfelt version of not just his best song, but one of the prettiest love songs the Beatles ever released, all the more meaningful given how rarely they wrote about love in the late 60s. This version is just George and his guitar, though the version on the Abbey Road set reveals a piano track too. Personally, I prefer this version.
‘Not Guilty’: Not fully recorded until George’s eponymous solo album in 1979, the Beatles version performed here is straight late-sixties rock and roll, with a really crunchy guitar part and George singing in a higher register than usual. It’s great!
‘Octopus’s Garden’: From the Abbey Road tapes, a joyful early take of Ringo’s second-ever song, with guide vocals, guitars, bass, and of course drums, sounding as good as they ever have. No one, and I mean no one, can drum like Ringo, and this track proves it.
‘All Things Must Pass’: In February 1969, on the occasion of his 26th birthday, George recorded the first demo of the song that will go on to become the title track of his first post-Beatles solo album, almost as if he sensed his Beatles days were rapidly coming to an end.
‘Come And Get It’: Paul’s demo of the Badfinger hit single, which would later turn out to become the theme from Ringo’s movie The Magic Christian. This is all Paul, surprisingly enough, even though it has that magic Beatles vibe. Not even his 3 McCartney albums sound like them!
‘Good Night’: This early version of the song begins with just piano and Ringo’s vocal, which then fades into the album mix because this take broke down. (I like it better with piano, personally.)
‘While My Guitar Gently Weeps’: A beautiful acoustic performance of probably my favorite White Album song of George’s, along with an organ part played by Paul. In 2006, this version of the song was the basis for its Love remix, which added a string section orchestrated by George Martin – the very last contribution he would make to a Beatles recording.
‘The Long And Winding Road’: As on Get Back, this is the same take of the song Phil Spector used for his infamous overdub session in 1970, but unmixed, which means you get to hear more of John’s bass playing, and Paul’s vocal is nice and dry compared to the Get Back mix, where it was soaked in reverb.
‘Real Love’: The second of three Beatles reunion songs, and the last one to be completed during the original ‘90s recording sessions. (“Now and Then” started here, but the technology to finish it wasn’t there yet.) While PG&R were not huge fans of this song, I’ve always really liked it – I feel like it’s an excellent summation of everything the band was about.
The Anthology era remains a fascinating corner of the band’s history, since it’s the only time the four of them got to tell their story in their way – and being who they were, they did it in as many media formats as possible. The docuseries, the albums, the book – three different ways of experiencing a musical miracle, in the eyes of the men who made it happen.
This Highlights collection has a lot of good tracks on it, but I think some aspects of their history get glossed over. There’s nothing from their years as a live band, for example, everything here is entirely studio based.
Even more jarringly, their mid-sixties psychedelic period is compressed into just five songs. Hell, Pepper doesn’t get an acknowledgment at all, unless “Strawberry Fields” counts. The best represented era of their career, funnily enough, is 1969, though even there, we have gaps.
Next week, the 2025 version of Highlights – vastly expanded compared to the 2011 version, but does it work as a compilation? We shall see!
Leave a Reply