Captain’s log, stardate 81386.6: Data is inspired by a cybernetics conference and announces that he has created Lal, an android ‘daughter’ – which does not please the captain at first, but when Admiral Haftell arrives with the intention of taking Lal, she experiences an irreversible malfunction.
This week, an episode that watches very differently in 2026 than it did in 1990. As with most TNG episodes in which Data is the focus character, much of the reason for that has to do with the first season of Star Trek: Picard, which explored (among other plot lines) Bruce Maddox’s attempts at creating more androids similar to Data.
“The Measure of a Man” from season 2 got the whole process started, what with the trial to determine Data’s sentience and rights as a living being – or even the fact that he was a living being in the first place. As I noted back then:
It wasn’t until 2020 when we got to the first season of Star Trek: Picard that we got to see the franchise return to the idea of androids as lifeforms, and the answer, despite the fact that Louvois’ precedent with Data should’ve carried weight, seemed to be no after all. Soong-type androids worked menial labor jobs on Mars, meaning that Starfleet really had built an army of disposable people, just as Guinan had feared it would.
Then synthetic lifeforms were banned following the Tal Shiar-instigated uprising, leading to (among other things) the death of Riker’s son and Bruce Maddox, the guy who tried to disassemble Data all those years ago, fleeing to another planet to continue his research outside of the Federation’s purview.
Picard, in his defense of Data, notes that the decision Louvois reaches “will reveal the kind of a people we are, what he is destined to be. […] It could significantly redefine the boundaries of personal liberty and freedom. Expanding them for some… savagely curtailing them for others.” The final analysis, taken with the first season of Picard in mind, is that despite Jean-Luc’s best efforts, the Federation doesn’t care about the rights of androids.
And that hypothesis is borne out here, where much of the episode centers around not only Data’s creation of a daughter (complete with allowing the basic golem to CHOOSE THEIR OWN GENDER, furthering the “Data as a transgender allegory” angle we discussed in the “Measure” post) but also the reactions of Picard and, later, Starfleet Command to the same.
What surprises me is Picard’s initial reaction to Lal. In a conversation with Troi early in the episode, he says this:
PICARD: I insist we do whatever we can to discourage the perception of this new android as a child. It is not a child. It is an invention, albeit an extraordinary one.
TROI: Why should biology rather than technology determine whether it is a child? Data has created an offspring. A new life out of his own being. To me, that suggests a child. If he wishes to call Lal his child, then who are we to argue?
PICARD: Well, if he must, but I fail to understand how a five foot android with heuristic learning systems and the strength of ten men can be called a child.
TROI: You’ve never been a parent.
What a distressingly conservative position, especially coming from the man who so passionately defended Data’s rights as a sentient being just last season! But then again, Picard does this all the time where Data is concerned. And just as in “Measure,” it takes Data’s own words with him in his ready room for Picard to come around to the problem of the week:
PICARD: Data, you are seeking to achieve what only your own creator has been able to achieve. To make another functioning, sentient, android. To make another Data.
DATA: That is why I must attempt this, sir. I have observed that in most species, there is a primal instinct to perpetuate themselves. Until now, I have been the last of my kind. If I were to be damaged or destroyed, I would be lost forever. But if I am successful with the creation of Lal, my continuance is assured. I understand the risk, sir. and I am prepared to accept the responsibility.
And so he does! As the episode unspools, Lal continues her progress, and evidently Picard comes around to the whole idea. He may not understand everything yet, but the fact that Data sees Lal as his child is enough for him – and that’s allyship enough. It’s much needed character development for Jean-Luc, and it will go on to pay off big time in the first season Picard.
What I like about this episode is that by the end, everyone is on Data’s side on this issue. Admiral Haftel, who spends much of the episode’s second half trying to separate Data from Lal (much to the latter’s fear) ends up being responsible, albeit accidentally for her death. He and Data try to save her life, but ultimately it goes nowhere, and he is very clearly deeply moved by what happened:
HAFTEL: There was nothing anyone could have done. We’d repolarise one pathway and another would collapse. And then another. His hands were moving faster than I could see, trying to stay ahead of each breakdown. He refused to give up. He was remarkable. It just wasn’t meant to be.
No, Lal doesn’t live to the end of the episode – this being episodic television, something as big as DATA HAVING A DAUGHTER NOW just isn’t in the cards. But Picard’s first season, free of obligations to hit the reset button at the end of every episode, is able to explore the ramifications of the concept in full detail.
That said, Lal does survive in a way. In the closing bridge scene, Data explains to Picard what he did to preserve something of Lal:
DATA: I thank you for your sympathy, but she is here. Her presence so enriched my life that I could not allow her to pass into oblivion. So I incorporated her programs back into my own. I have transferred her memories to me.
There’s a certain amount of irony in that Melinda Snodgrass didn’t want to do it, but the actual writer, René Echevarria, is actually quite fond of the work, as was head writer Michael Piller: “The perfect show to follow ‘Yesterday’s Enterprise’ and a totally different kind of episode. The script and performances were great. […] My taste, it was as good a show as we had all year. When you have good character stuff, you’ve got my support.”
And of course, this episode served as the directorial debut for Jonathan Frakes! I’ve always enjoyed his work as a director on Star Trek, and he goes on to have quite a long list of episodes under his name – 33 episodes in total, with TNG, Discovery, and Picard making up most of those credits, plus two TNG movies – First Contact and Insurrection. And what a fantastic episode to start off with, too! IMO, his episodes are generally the best ones.
Next time: Something completely different! It’s a Worf episode, and a very important one, as it marks TNG’s first foray into arc-based television. It’s “Sins of the Father!”
Leave a Reply