Captain’s log, stardate 81406.2: The Enterprise receives a Klingon first officer on the Federation exchange program who is actually Worf’s brother. When Worf learns that their father has been charged with betraying the Khitomer Outpost, he sets off on a mission to clear his family name.
Welcome back! This week we get one of my favorite Worf episodes of the whole show, a true deep dive into Klingon politics, and Captain Picard gets to put his diplomacy skills to work, up to and including telling DURAS HIMSELF to essentially fuck off in the classiest way imaginable. The way the episode starts up though, you’d think this is a sequel to last season’s “A Matter of Honor,” with the roles reversed.
Tthis time, it’s Kurn serving aboard a Starfleet ship, and when he speaks with the main bridge crew, poor Wesley ends up getting hit with the full brunt of Kurn’s vastly different command style. And then there’s Worf, whom Kurn constantly patronizes in their early scenes together:
WORF: Sensors picking up asteroidal debris ahead, Commander.
KURN: Can you identify the coordinates, Mister Worf?
WORF: Bearing zero zero one mark point oh three. Range, three hundred thousand kilometres.
KURN: Excellent. Please scan the asteroid field for me, Lieutenant, and report.
WORF: Approximately two thousand small objects. None in our direct flight path, sir.
KURN: So, no course correction is necessary. Is that what you are saying?
WORF: It should not be needed, sir.
KURN: Very good, Lieutenant. You handled that well.
As the episode unspools, we learn why Kurn treats Worf the way he does – what he knows, and what Worf and the audience don’t know, is that Kurn and Worf are brothers, and this is their first meeting. (After all, Worf was raised by human parents on Earth.)
He reveals this fact after challenging Worf’s Klingon-ness, implying that he has been made weak by serving on a Starfleet ship all this time. (Worf throws a chair at him in reply.) In the scene following the act break, Kurn catches Worf up on the past, and then drops the real reason for his visit to the Enterprise: The Klingon High Council has judged Mogh, their father, a traitor to the Empire, and it is Worf’s role to mount a challenge.
Picard’s response? Order the Enterprise to travel to the Klingon homeworld, so Picard can stand at his officer’s side during the trial.
And as for who’s responsible for all this shit? The House of Duras, who will go on to be a thorn in the side of the Enterprise crew all the way to Star Trek: Generations. Duras himself injures Kurn, and Picard steps into the role of Worf’s Cha’DIch – ritual second. (Notably, Picard confirms his agreement by speaking in Klingon.)
In the end though, Worf doesn’t get his name cleared – instead he is sentenced to discommendation, a stain that will remain with him for the last third of season three and all of season four, before finally being resolved in the magnificent two-parter “Redemption.” It turns out that it was Duras’ father, Ja’rod, who was in cahoots with the Romulans, but there was nothing to be done about it, as the Duras family had become too powerful for the Empire to survive a direct challenge.
Still, this episode is notable for being TNG’s earliest go at the kind of serialized storytelling style that other Treks, like Deep Space Nine, Discovery, and Picard, would go on to refine in the future. TNG remains largely episodic through to the end of the series, but there are still recurring plot threads that are built upon in later seasons, and in the case of Worf’s relationship to his own people, well into DS9 as well.
As Ron Moore explains: “All the Worf stories spring from that moment, and also opened up the whole franchise to the idea that maybe we can do continuing stories. It was really a pivotal moment looking back on how we structured Next Generation.”
It won’t surprise you, I’m sure, that Ronald D. Moore wrote much of the episode’s teleplay, given that he also contributed “The Bonding” earlier in the season. He said of this episode, “I was in love with ‘Sins of the Father’ and I fought for it when there was some question about which way we were going to go with it. I really like the fact Worf took it on the chin that episode. It said he was willing to stand up and do the right thing for his people, even if they weren’t going to do the right thing by him.”
This is one of the things I’ve always liked about Worf. Because he had to learn about his own people largely from books rather than first-hand experience, he ends up being a much better Klingon than most of the others of his kind that we see. K’mpec and Kurn aren’t too bad, but Duras?! That dude is a piece of shit all the way down.
And then there’s Picard, who more than earns his pips this week in the way he unflinchingly stands by Worf throughout all of this, including risking his own life to ensure that Mogh’s name is cleared. Sure, it doesn’t work, but it still speaks to the kind of person he is that this is something that would even cross his mind.
And of course, this episode is proof beyond measure of exactly why Patrick Stewart, professional Shakespearean actor, was exactly the man to play Picard. He has to do a lot of shouting in this episode, and Stewart’s stage-honed delivery and clipped received pronunciation accent is key to making it work, to say nothing of how, as per Making It So, he channeled some of his father in Picard. I can see Sergeant Major Alfred Stewart in how Patrick plays some of his lines, especially near the end.
Finally, I also want to talk about just how amazing this episode looks in HD. The Klingon planet scenes in particular look wonderful, with the dim lighting and dark shadows adding to the impression that Klingon culture is as far from the squeaky clean United Federation of Planets as possible.
What I like about this episode is that it doesn’t end in the way we expect of TNG, with the real traitor unmasked and Worf’s name is cleared. Instead, everything that Worf and Picard go through end up coming to nothing, because as K’mpec himself admits, the trial was over before it started: “His challenge was defeated before he ever made it.”
Kangaroo courts, huh? Yeah, I know how that goes.
Leave a Reply