As we’ve talked about before, the Beatles’ contracts with EMI (and thus their own Apple label) ended in 1975. Paul’s final Apple record was Band on the Run, released in 1973, while Ringo’s swansong was Goodnight Vienna from 1974, released around the same time as Walls and Bridges. (Ringo and John even narrated TV commercials for the other’s album.) John’s goodbye to Apple, and the music business in general until 1980, was the covers album Rock ’n’ Roll, overproduced for disc by Phil Spector.
Extra Texture has the somewhat infamous reputation of being not just George’s final album for the label he co-founded in 1968, but the final studio album released by Apple Records as a label until the 1990s, when it went defunct for around 20 years until the first Live at the BBC compilation came out. Since then, Apple Records has mainly been the label for various Beatles remaster projects, from the Anthologies to the “Now and Then” single from 2023.
But getting back to Extra Texture. This album represents a number of departures from the form for George – there are no spiritual messages included here, and the sound is best described as George’s foray into soul music rather than straight rock. It was recorded mainly in Los Angeles rather than the UK, and as a final nod to the imminent end of the Apple label, a picture of an apple core features on the front of the CD and vinyl labels of the album.
Let’s dig in:
‘You’: Not much to say here, just George doing his own version of a song originally recorded for Ronnie Spector in 1971. Later on, he dug out the backing track and recorded new vocals for it, even keeping the original key even though it was a bit outside his range. Listen closely, and you can still hear Spector’s guide vocal.
‘The Answer’s At The End’: Another Frankie Crisp song, this time in the first verse: “Scan not a friend with a microscopic glass. You know his faults now let his foibles pass. Life is one long enigma true my friend. Read on, read on, the answer’s at the end.” Other inspirations here include Nina Simone’s version of “Isn’t It A Pity” from ATMP, including two lines of lyrics and the slow, stately tempo.
‘This Guitar (Can’t Keep From Crying)’: As we talked about last week, music critics absolutely savaged George’s album and tour from 1974. This pissed him off so much that he decided to write a song in response, dismissing his critics: “While you attack, create offence/I’ll put it down to your ignorance”.
George wrote in 1980: “It’s ‘son of’ ‘While My Guitar Gently Weeps’. I decided to write that song because of the popularity of ‘While My Guitar Gently Weeps’. It was really just like a cheap excuse to play a big of guitar. And that song, ‘Guitar Gently Weeps’, was actually more popular than I realised. That was the one song particularly that went down very well. And it seems to have been quite a popular one of my songs off the old Beatle albums. So I thought I’d write another one. Son of.”
This song was later re-recorded in the 1990s, with additional overdubs added in 2006 for Dave Stewart’s Platinum Weird project. That version was released on the 2014 remaster of the album as part of the Apple Years box set.
‘Ooh Baby (You Know That I Love You)’: In which George writes a Smokey Robinson-type number, inspired by a 1965 hit single with the Miracles. Robinson, of course, is someone we’ve talked about before – John and George covered another song of his, “You Really Got a Hold on Me,” on With The Beatles. This is one of two Smokey-inspired songs by George, the other is “Pure Smokey” on Thirty Three & 1/3.
‘World Of Stone’: George in a radio interview from 1975: “I wrote that a couple of years ago, and only just got round to recording it. There’s not much of a story to it really, other than “Wise men you won’t be/To follow the like of me/In this world made of stone”. It’s really just down to saying that everybody has their own opinion and right to be, that’s really all. It’s a nice melody.”
‘A Bit More Of You’: A reprise of the opening track, starting off side two of the original vinyl edition.
‘Can’t Stop Thinking About You’: George in 1975: “I wrote that one at Christmastime two years ago. I was just sitting round the log fire. I always hear someone like Joe Cocker singing that one. It’s a very commercial sort of song. The middle part kills me. I don’t know what it is, I have this tendency to write dramatic or melodramatic melodies, and that one, it’s like there’s a song on Material World also, which always makes me think it should be sung by somebody like either Al Jolson or Mario Lanza. It’s a funny, interesting melody.”
‘Tired Of Midnight Blue’: George in 1980: “‘Tired Of Midnight Blue’ was originally called ‘Midnight Blue’ and as soon as I had it ready Melissa Manchester put out a song with that title and so I changed it to ‘Tired Of Midnight Blue’. I had been to a Los Angeles club – ended up in the back room with a lot of grey-haired naughty people and I was depressed by what I saw going on there.”
‘Grey Cloudy Lies’: In which George, in the tradition of John Lennon, writes about the hell that he’s currently going through, indulging on drink and drugs and generally having an utterly miserable time. He said in 1975: “That’s one of those depressing, four o’clock in the morning sort of songs. I don’t know where these songs come from half the time. That one was a piano song. […] I think it was just one of those songs after talking for a lot, you know, sometimes it’s nice to be quiet.”
‘His Name Is ‘Legs’ (Ladies And Gentlemen)’: Of all things, a tribute to “Legs” Larry Smith of the Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band, last seen here on the blog for their appearance at the end of the Magical Mystery Tour film, where they performed the song “Death Cab For Cutie” while a stripper did… well, what strippers do. Legs appears on the recording, singing two lines of each bridge and some spoken-word improv near the end.
As George said in 1975: “Anyway, I met him two years ago, a lot happened that Christmas. I had this piano around the fire. I just met Larry, he kept coming and going, and he just amazed me, all the things he was saying, so I decided to write a song about him. So the lyrics are just crazy, you know, just like Larry, actually.”
For all that George was visibly having a difficult time for much of 1974 and ’75, I actually quite like Extra Texture. The keyboard-heavy sonic palette is immediately distinctive compared to his earlier guitar-based albums, and the soul inspirations clearly got him excited to make music again.
And yet, I seem to be the only person in the world who likes this record – critics hated it in the 1970s and they hate it now. Even George himself didn’t like it, in 1987 he said: “The production left a lot to be desired, as did my performance … Some songs I like, but in retrospect I wasn’t very happy about it.”
Whatever. I’ve gone against the grain before and I’ll do it again.
Leave a Reply