I’ve always had a soft spot for Doctor Who’s many book lines. This goes back to around 2006 or 2007, when I was in middle school. My school’s library had three of the classic series Target novelizations available: Doctor Who and the Cybermen, Doctor Who and the Green Death, and Doctor Who and the Curse of Peladon. Long... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: Resolution Review
Let’s just abandon all pretense and call the damn thing Resolution of the Daleks, because that’s the better title. You could’ve led with that and got a built-in audience, because everyone loves a Dalek story, especially in the first season for the new Doctor. But then, papering over the complete lack of substance in your product... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: Series 11 Review
So, here we are: after a truncated run of only ten episodes, the first series of the Chibnall/Whittaker era has come to an end. Obviously, there was a lot riding on this series, given the importance of Whittaker’s casting. But was it a success? To be honest? Not really. At least, not for me. The... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: The Battle of Ranskoor av Kolos Review
As much as I tried to go in blind, I couldn’t. I glimpsed a headline suggesting that Doctor Who fans were disappointed by a boring finale, and opinions in the Eruditorum Press Discord seemed negative at best. And I still, for the life of me, cannot remember the episode title beyond the first three words.... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: It Takes You Away Review
I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again: the guest episodes remain the strong point of the Chibnall era. Even Kerblam, for all its appalling politics, felt like a well-constructed Doctor Who episode, as did Demons, Witchfinders, and now this. In fact, I’d even say that this week’s episode was the strongest of the lot. In a... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: The Witchfinders Review
I already know what I’m going to say: this was one of the best episodes of the series. Partly this is because it was a historical, (and the historicals have all been excellent this year) but also because this is more of a traditional historical in the way that Rosaand Demons of the Punjab weren’t. The main rule... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: Kerblam Review
I had such high hopes for the episode. And to be fair, from a construction standpoint it’s fantastic. It doesn’t suffer from the lack of resolution issues so many episodes of this series have. From a plot standpoint it’s somewhere between Planet of the Ood with echoes of The Beast Below in the design of the delivery bots.... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: Demons of the Punjab Review
If there’s one thing that can be said about historical episodes in the Chibnall era, it’s that they are the closest the show has come to doing a standard pure historical since 1982’s Black Orchid. Sure, Rosa was more of the celebrity variation that was introduced in the Davies era, but it also wasn’t a romp like... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: The Tsuranga Conundrum Review
Well. That was certainly an episode of television. It was mildly entertaining, and unlike the other solo Chibnall scripts this year it actually contained this marvelous invention called a “resolution,” in which all the major elements of the episode (the fatal disease the general has, the pregnant man about to give birth, the monster) are... Continue Reading →
The Mactíre Anthology: Arachnids in the UK Review
FINALLY! What we have here, for my money, is easily Chibnall’s best script of the series, at least so far. Unlike his first two episodes this year, this one doesn’t run around with a bunch of half-formed plot ideas that ultimately go nowhere. It’s tight and focused, telling one complete story and leaving it at... Continue Reading →