The odd thing about Doctor Who is that, for a British TV show, it has a weird association with American historical catastrophes: the premiere of the classic series was overshadowed by the murder of President Kennedy in Texas the day before, while Rose premiered exactly two years and six days into the Iraq war. Looking... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: The Unquiet Dead
This week, the first Doctor Who Christmas story of the modern era. I said story, not special: the original episode aired in April 2005, not December, and the brevity of Eccleston’s tenure means that he doesn’t really get a “Christmas special” onscreen. (His Doctor gets a few in spin-off media though.) So this is what... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: The End of the World
One of the things Davies had to do when bringing Doctor Who back was show off the range of stories the show can tell, and the kinds of things it can do. To help accomplish this, he set up a basic template that all of his seasons follow: an opening triptych of modern-day Earth/far future/distant... Continue Reading →
Adventures of Narrative Substitution: The Power of the Doctor
So, here we are: the final entry in Adventures in Narrative Substitution, the final post on the Chibnall era I'll ever write, and the next-to-last one you'll read, as the 42 post in The RTD Rewind will come out after this. It's taken a long time to get here, but the end is in sight.... Continue Reading →
It’s Not Me, It’s Who: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Watch Star Trek
2018 was probably the last year I considered myself a Doctor Who fan. The liminal space between Twice Upon A Timeand The Woman Who Fell to Earth was filled with possibility: we didn’t know anything about the Jodie Whittaker era yet, as those involved with making it were being very tight-lipped. (This would turn out... Continue Reading →
Circles: Reflections on Nostalgia
It’s May 16th, 2022. David Tennant will be returning as the Doctor alongside Catherine Tate in what looks like every dream that a certain contingent of Doctor Who fans have been having coming true once and for all: their preferred Doctor, showrunner, and companion back in control, the way things should be. A grand reset... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Legend of the Sea Devils
First of all, I’d like to begin by shamelessly plugging my new book, the second volume of the Back to the Eleventh Hourtrilogy of critical essays on the era of the Eleventh Doctor. It covers series six, a truly mad and ambitious season of the show if there ever was one. Yes, the same description... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Eve of the Daleks
I’ve talked a lot over the course of this series about queerness, and in particular, the Chibnall era’s continual failures to deliver. I don’t think I’m being at all hyperbolic when I say that his era of the show is easily the most cis-het of the New Series so far. And when queer characters have... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Vanquishers
My usual thing for this series is to contrast the Chibnall era with something else, but as with the Survivors/Kroll post, I can’t really do that this time: in this case, the writers are too much alike. Chibnall, Bob Baker, and Dave Martin all attempt to make Doctor Who into Epic Television. The vast majority... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Survivors of the Flux
The thing that happens when you decide to swap one season story arc for another is that eventually, you end up comparing two stories that are both kind of shit. Graham Williams hated it, Robert Holmes himself hated it, Mary Tamm hated it, everyone hated it except the viewing public of 1978, who gave it... Continue Reading →