At one time, I might have spent the bulk of this essay discussing how this episode is the first shot in the bow of a move away from the celebrity historical model that’s dominated the new series since the show returned in 2005 - a format inaugurated by, funnily enough, Mark Gatiss. But that’s the... Continue Reading →
The Midnight Hour: Life Ain’t All Bad (Into the Dalek)
Nothing, and I mean nothing, solidifies a new Doctor quite like their first Dalek story. Eccleston, of course, got Dalek for his first and only face-off against our favorite alien exterminators, and it was fucking brilliant, as I wrote in a review that no less a figure than ROB FREAKING SHEARMAN approved of. (He told... Continue Reading →
The Midnight Hour: Time Enough for Rocking When We’re Old (Deep Breath)
It was always the plan that I was going to do a Capaldi series. When you set out to write episodic analyses of the period of Doctor Who that has defined your very being as a person, to tell one half of the story without telling the other would be like leaving a song unfinished... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: Spirits of Ancient Egypt (The Legend of Ruby Sunday/Empire of Death)
After what could otherwise be described as the most accessible season of the show in six years, with no returning villains (kinda-sorta) and fairly light-hearted stories, RTD unexpectedly hits us with one of the darkest finales the show has done in a long time - only Dark Water quite matches it. (And funnily enough, that... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: I Want to Hold Your Hand (Rogue)
As we approach the finale of this surprisingly short season, (if you don’t factor in the 60th and Ruby Road as part of the count, though you should, because it brings us up to twelve) we find ourselves in the odd position of coming to the end of what literally is RTD’s second-ever first season... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: Friends to Go (Dot and Bubble)
That moment where your devotion to the idea of using Beatles lyrics to title your blog posts feels like a mistake, because then it means you can’t use the perfect Duran Duran title instead. Two of them, actually: “Networker Nation” or “Bury A Friend,” which I realize is a Billie Eilish cover. So instead, we... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: All the Lonely People (73 Yards)
“Well, we're the Unified Intelligence Taskforce, created to investigate the extraterrestrial and, more and more, the supernatural,” says Kate Stewart, roughly halfway through this episode. “Things seem to be turning that way these days.” Aside from this being RTD yelling “WE’RE A FANTASY SHOW NOW” at the top of his voice, the new engagement with... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: Give Peace A Chance (Boom)
Back in 2017, I really thought we’d never see a new Steven Moffat Doctor Who story again. Then it turned out he’d novelized The Day of the Doctor (which both old and new at the same time, thanks to all the narrative changes) and then penned a bunch of short pieces for the lockdown-era Tweetalongs... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: Nothing You Can Sing That Can’t Be Sung (The Devil’s Chord)
Let’s just get one thing straight: The Devil’s Chord is not a Beatles historical. Or rather, it’s not a Beatles historical in the usual great-men-of-history mode that the show worked in during the original Davies era and the Chibnall era. Like, yes, the Beatles are there and the show fawns over them, what with the... Continue Reading →
Across the Universe: Cry Baby Cry (Space Babies)
It’s been a very long time since I’ve been able to say this, so I’ll say it now: I enjoyed watching Doctor Who. Like, over the past several years, I very quickly and rather publicly fell out of love with Who and fell into Star Trek. (If you read my old Adventures in Narrative Substitution series,... Continue Reading →